Archives
The Decision to Outsource: A Case Study of the Complex Interplay Between Strategic Wisdom and Behavioural Reality
James D Hunter
New England Business School, University of New England, Armidale NSW
Ray W Cooksey
New England Business School, University of New England, Armidale NSW
Abstract
The last two decades have seen an unprecedented growth in the use of outsourcing interventions in diverse organisational contexts. This phenomenon can be viewed as a means of unbundling the vertically integrated activities of organisations in response to existing strategic wisdoms that focus upon value-creating activities as a means of enhancing an organisation's sustainable competitive advantage. This paper explores the delicate balance between these more conventional strategic motives and the more complex, emergent and interconnected behavioural impacts and considerations in the context of a decision to outsource the meter reading activities of a well-established, publicly listed Australian energy company. By drawing upon the idiosyncratic experiences reported by particular groups of individuals involved in, or affected by, an outsourcing decision, the authors note some important lessons that may inform the pursuit of such decisions in the future.
In recent years the outsourcing phenomenon has fundamentally altered the processing and delivery of a wide range of goods and services by organisations in public, private and not-for-profit sectors (Auguste et al 2002; Osterman 1998; Industry Commission 1996; Domberger & Hall 1995). Despite the stellar rise of outsourcing as a mainstream management tool, outsourcing's proponents seem unable to successfully distance themselves from ongoing questioning of the rationale for, and fallout resulting from, its adoption (Jennings 2002: Doig et al 2001; Humphry 2000: Hunter & Gates 1998; Commonwealth Ombudsman 1996; Rees & Rodley 1995).
Much of the debate and research relating to outsourcing has been informed by the principles of transaction cost economics (Williamson 1979; Williamson 1975; Coase 1937) whereby the make-or-buy decision is crystallised by simply comparing the costs of managing transactions (using the market) with production costs (producing internally). In short, the transaction cost approach suggests that markets are most efficient for all transactions, except those that involve assets of a highly specialised nature used frequently as these represent a set of circumstances open to opportunistic behaviour by the market.
However, the hard lessons learned with the passage of time have shown (the informed observer) that managers who limit their sourcing decisions to cost comparisons alone are likely to run the risk of seeing their organisation wither and die: rigorous cost analysis is a part, albeit an important part, of a plethora of other strategic considerations that combine to move an organisation toward its long-term goals and objectives (Fill & Viser 2000; Rule 1999; Meredith 1998; Domberger 1998; Hunter & Gates 1998: Hodge 1996: Kochan et al 1994). Indeed, this strategic context forms the cornerstone from which this paper proceeds to explore the appropriateness and meaningfulness of the strategic literature's conception of outsourcing decisions for the realities of a complex and dynamic operating environment.
References
Abrahamson E (1991) Managerial fads and fashions: The diffusion and rejection of innovations, Academy of Management Review 16(2), pp. 586-612.
Auguste BG, Hao Y, Singer M and Wiegand M (2002) The other side of outsourcing, The McKinsey Quarterly 1, pp. 53-63.
Beinhocker ED (1997) Strategy at the edge of chaos, The McKinsey Quarterly 1, pp. 24-39.
Boisot M (2000) Is there a complexity beyond the reach of strategy? The McKinsey Quarterly 2, pp. 114-134.
Bonn I (1996) Strategic Management in Australian Organisations. PhD thesis, Swinbourne University of Technology, Melbourne.
Brown SL and Eisenhardt KM (1998) Competing on the edge: Strategy and structured chaos, Harvard Business School Press, Boston.
Charmaz K (1998) Grounded theory: Objectivist and constructivist methods, in NK Denzin and YS Lincoln (eds) The landscape of qualitative research: Theories and issues. Sage Publications, Thousand Oaks, pp. 509-535.
Coase RH (1937) The nature of the firm, Economica 4(16) pp. 386-405.
Commonwealth Ombudsman (1996) Commonwealth Ombudsman Annual Report, Australian Government Publishing Services, Canberra.
Cooksey RW (2000a) Scaling the peaks of business strategy: When visibility is poor; the ground keeps moving and the climbing party can't seem to stay together, UNE 2000 Inaugural Lecture Series, Armidale.
Cooksey RW (2000b) Mapping the texture of managerial decision making: A complex dynamic decision perspective, Emergence 2(2) pp. 102-122.
Creswell JW (1998) Qualitative inquiry and research design: Choosing among five traditions, Sage Publications, London.
Denzin NK and Lincoln YS (eds) (1998) The landscape of qualitative research: Theories and issues. Sage Publications, Thousand Oaks.
Doig SJ, Ritter RC, Speckhals K and Woodson D (2001) Has outsourcing gone too far? The Mckinsey Quarterly 4, pp. 24-37.
Domberger S (1998) The contracting organization: A strategic guide to outsourcing, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
Domberger S and Hall C (eds) (1995) The contracting casebook: Competitive tendering in action, Australian Government Publishing Services, Canberra.
Fill C and Viser E (2000) The outsourcing dilemma: A composite approach to the make or buy decision, Management Decision 38(1) pp. 43-50.
Fischili I (1996) Outsourcing: A new management tool or just a fad? Bulletin of the American Society for Information Science 22(4) pp. 20-21.
Gahan C and Hannibal M (1998) Doing qualitative research using QSR NUD*IST, Sage publications, London.
Glaser BG and Strauss AL (1967) The discovery of grounded theory: Strategies for qualitative research. Aldine Gruyter, New York.
Hamel G (1996) Strategy as revolution. Harvard Business Review 74(4) pp. 69-82.
Hodge G (1996) Contracting out government services: A review of international evidence, Montech Pty Ltd, Melbourne.
Humphry R (2000) Review of the whole of government information technology outsourcing initiative, Commonwealth Government Publishing Services, Canberra.
Hunter JD and Cooksey RW (2003) Discovering strategic lessons for 'surfing' the outsourcing wave and avoiding the 'wipe-outs', electronic proceeding from the 17th annual conference of the Australian and New Zealand Academy of Management, Fremantle, Western Australia.
Hunter JD and Gates GR (1998) Outsourcing: Functional, fashionable or foolish? In G Griffin (ed) Management theory and practice: Moving to a new era, Macmillan Education Australia, Melbourne, pp. 133-144.
Industry Commission (1996) Competitive tendering and contracting by public sector agencies, (Report no 48) Australian Government Publishing Services, Melbourne.
Jackson MC (2003) Systems thinking: Creative holism for management, John Wiley and Sons Ltd, Chichester.
Jennings D (2002) Strategic sourcing: Benefits, problems and a contextual model, Management Decision 40(1) pp. 26-34.
Kochan TA, Smith M, Wells JC and Rebitzer JB (1994) Human resource strategies and contingent workers: The case of safety and health in the petroleum industry. Human Resource Management 33(1) pp. 55-77.
Lonsdale C and Cox A (2000) The historical development of outsourcing: The latest fad? Industrial Management and Data Systems 100(9) pp. 444-450.
Marton F and Booth S (1997) Learning and awareness, Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Mahwah.
Meredith H (1998) Crisis in critical infrastructure, Australian Financial Review 6 August, p. 11.
Midgley G (2000) Systemic intervention: Philosophy, methodology, and practice, Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers, New York.
Miles MB and Huberman AM (1994) An expanded sourcebook: Qualitative data analysis, 2nd edn, Sage Publications, Thousand Oaks.
Minichiello V, Aroni R, Timewell E and Alexander L (1995) In-depth interviewing: Principles, techniques, analysis, Addison Wesley Longman Australia. Melbourne.
Mintzberg H (1990) The design school: Reconsidering the basic premises of strategic management, Strategic Management Journal 11, pp. 171-195.
Osterman P (1998) Employment factors: Reorganisation, dislocation and public policy, Oxford University Press. Oxford.
Parker D and Stacey R (1995) Chaos, management and economics: The implications of non-linear thinking, The Centre for Independent Studies. Sydney.
Patton MQ (2002) Qualitative research and evaluation methods, 3rd edn, Sage Publications, Thousand Oaks, CA.
Peters T and Waterman RH (1982) In search of excellence, Harper Collins, Sydney.
Porter ME (1985) Competitive advantage: Creating and sustaining superior performance, Free Press, New York.
Porter ME (1996) What is strategy? Harvard Business Review 74(6) pp. 61-78.
Prahalad CK and Hamel G (1990) The core competencies of the corporation, Harvard Business Review 68(3) pp. 79-91.
Priesmeyer HR (1992) Organizations and chaos: Defining the methods of nonlinear management, Quorum Books, Westport, CN.
Qualitative Solutions and Research Pty Ltd (1997) QSR NUD*IST 4 Users Guide, 2nd edn, La Trobe University, Melbourne.
Quinn JB and Hilmer FG (1994) Strategic outsourcing, Sloane Management Review 35(4) pp. 43-55.
Rees S and Rodley G (eds) (1995) The human cost of managerialism, Pluto Press, Sydney.
Reilly P and Tamkin P (1996) Outsourcing: A flexible option for the future? The Institute for Employment Studies, University of Sussex, Brighton.
Rothery B and Roberts L (1995) The truth about outsourcing, Gower Publishing, Aldershot.
Rule A (1999) A death that should not have been, The Age 21 March, pp. 10-11.
Rumelt RP (1974) Strategy, structure and economic performance, Harvard University Press, Cambridge.
Senge PM (1990) The fifth discipline: The art and practice of the learning organization, Random House Australia, Sydney.
Shapiro EC (1995) Fad surfing in the boardroom: Reclaiming the courage to manage in the age of instant answers, Harper Collins Publishers, Sydney.
Stacey RD (1996) Strategic management and organisational dynamics: The challenge of complexity, 4th edn, Prentice Hall, London.
Strauss AL and Corbin J (1990) Basics of qualitative research: Grounded theory procedures and techniques, Sage Publications, Newberry Park.
Williamson OE (1975) Markets and hierarchies: Analysis and antitrust implications, Free Press, New York.
Williamson OE (1979) Transaction cost economics: The governance of contractual relations, Journal of Law and Economics 22(2) pp. 233-261.
Yin RK (2003) Case study research: Design and methods, Sage Publications, Thousand Oaks, CA.
eContent Home
