Archives
Factors Influencing Governance Choice and Human Resource Management within Services Franchising Networks
Scott Weaven
Griffith Business School, Department of Marketing, Griffith University - Gold Coast campus, Southport QLD, Australia
Carmel Herington
Griffith Business School, Department of Marketing, Griffith University - Gold Coast campus, Southport QLD, Australia
Abstract
This research provides a better understanding of the factors driving the choice of governance structures and human resource management (HRM) practices within services franchising arrangements.
A qualitative multiple case study approach was favoured so as to obtain a clearer picture of the main issues and parameters. Nineteen franchisors using predominantly pure franchising, predominantly pure company-owned, plural, and predominantly multiple unit growth strategies were interviewed.
Major contrasts have been identified, suggesting that system size, industry maturity and the nature of market demand impacts upon the choice of system governance structure. Generally, less mature and smaller networks rely upon predominantly single unit franchising strategies and less sophisticated HRM practices to foster local market innovation, build brand value and support rapid unit growth, while predominantly company owned strategies are favoured in environments of low competition and minimal demand uncertainty.
In comparison, more mature systems use hybridised franchising forms and sophisticated HRM strategies to accommodate the competing demands of local market innovation, systemwide adaptation and system uniformity.
Keywords
franchising, plural, multiple unit, HRM, mutual learning
References
Achrol RS (1996) The franchise as a network organisation. Proceedings of the 10th Annual Society of Franchising Conference, Partners for Progress...a World of Opportunities, A Dugan (ed), Hilton Hawaiian Village, Honolulu, Hawaii.
Alchian AA and Demsetz H (1972) Production, information costs, and economics organisation, American Economic Review 62: 777-795.
Bergen M, Dutta S and Walker O (1992) Agency relationships in marketing: A review of the implications and applications of agency and related theories, Journal of Marketing 56(1):1-24.
Birley G and Moreland N (1998) A Practical Guide to Academic Research, London, Kogan Page.
Bradach JL (1998) Franchise Organisations, Boston, Harvard University Press.
Bradach JL (1997) Using the plural form in the management of restaurant chains, Administrative Science Quarterly 42:276-303.
Bradach J L (1995) Chains within chains: The role of multi-unit franchisees, Journal of Marketing Channels 4(1/2):65-81.
Brickley J and Dark F & Weisbach M (1991) An agency perspective on franchising, Financial Management (1):27-35.
Carson D, Gilmore D, Perry C and Gronhaug K (2001) Qualitative Marketing Research, Sage Publications, Great Britain.
Castrogiovanni G and Justis RT (1998) Franchising configurations and transitions, Journal of Consumer Marketing 15(2):170-190.
Caves R and Murphy WII (1976) Franchising: firms, markets and tangible assets, Southern Economic Journal 42(4):572-586.
Chow L and Frazer L (2003) Servicing customers directly: Mobile franchising arrangements in Australia, European Journal of Marketing 37(3/4): 594-613.
Cliquet G (2000) Plural form in store networks: A model for store network evolution, The International Review of Retail, Distribution and Consumer Research 10(4): 369-87.
Cliquet G and Croizean J (2002) Towards plural forms, franchising/company-owned systems in the French cosmetics retail industry. International Journal of Retail and Distribution Management 30(5): 238-250.
Combs JG and Castrogiovanni G (1994) Franchisor strategy: A proposed model and empirical test of franchise vs. company ownership, Journal of Small Business Management 32(2): 37-48.
Dahlstrom R and Nygaard A (1994) A preliminary investigation of franchised oil distribution in Norway, Journal of Retailing 70(2): 179-191.
Dant RP (1995) Motivation for franchising: Rhetoric vs reality, International Small Business Journal 14(1):10-32.
Dant RP and Gundlach GT (1998) The challenge of autonomy and dependence in franchised channels of distribution, Journal of Business Venturing 14(1): 35-67.
Dant RP and Nasr NI (1998) Control Techniques and Upward Flow of Information in Franchising in Distant Markets: Conceptualization and Preliminary Evidence, Journal of Business Venturing 13(1): 3-28.
Deshpande R (1983) 'Paradigms lost': On theory and method in research marketing, Journal of Marketing 47(Fall):101-110.
Eisenhardt KM (1989) Building theories from case study research, Academy of Management Review 14(4): 532-550.
Elango B and Fried V (1997) Franchising research: A literature review and synthesis, Journal of Small Business Management 35(3): 68-81.
Feagin J, Orum A and Sjoberg G (eds) (1991) A case for case study, Chapel Hill, NC, University of North Carolina Press.
Frazer L (2000) Assessing franchising sector maturity: Australian evidence, Australasian Marketing Journal 8(2): 33-46.
Frazer L and Weaven S (2004) Franchising Australia 04. Brisbane, Griffith University: 1-71.
Frazer L, Weaven S and Wright S (2006) Franchising Australia 06, Griffith University/ Franchise Council of Australia: Brisbane: 1-71.
Glaser B and Strauss A (1967) The discovery of grounded theory: Strategies for qualitative research. New York, Aldine.
Gibb S (2001) The state of human resource management: evidence from employees' views of HRM systems and staff, Employee Relations 23(4/5): 318-336.
Goulding C (2002) Grounded Theory: A Practical Guide For Management, Business and Market Researchers, Sage, London.
Hunt SD (1973) The trends toward company operated units in franchise chains, Journal of Retailing 49(2): 2-12.
Jain S (1989) Standardisation of international marketing strategy: Some research hypotheses, Journal of Marketing 53: 70-79.
Jambulingam T and Nevin JR (1999) Influence on franchisee selection criteria on outcomes desired by the franchisor, Journal of Business Venturing 14: 363-395.
Johnson BR (1997) Examining the validity structure of qualitative research, Education 118(2): 282-292.
Kalnins A and Lafontaine F (1999) Incentive and strategic motives for vertical separation: Evidence from location patterns in the Texan fast food industry, Working paper, University of Michigan.
Kaufmann PJ (1996) The state of research in franchising. Franchising Research: An International Journal 1(1): 4-7.
Kaufmann PJ (1992) The impact of managerial performance decay on franchisors' store allocation strategies, Journal of Marketing Channels 1(4): 51-80.
Kaufmann, PJ and Dant RP (1998) Franchising and the domain of entrepreneurship research, Journal of Business Venturing 14(1): 5-16.
Kaufmann PJ and Dant RP (1996) Multi-unit franchising: growth and management issues, Journal of Business Venturing 11(5): 343-358.
Kaufmann PJ and Ergolu S (1998) Standardisation and adaptation in business format franchising, Journal of Business Venturing 14(1): 69-85.
Kaufmann PJ and Kim SH (1995) Master franchising and system growth rates. In Franchising: Contemporary Issues and Research (eds) Kaufmann PJ and Dant RP, Harword Press, New York: 49-64.
Koch MJ and McGrath RG (1996) Improving Labor Productivity: Human resource management policies do matter, Strategic Management Journal 17: 335-354.
Kvale S (1989) Issues of Validity in Qualitative Research, Krieger Publishing Company.
Lafontaine F (1999) Franchising: myth, reality and what it may all mean to you, Financial Times, Mastering Strategy Series, November 22 1999.
Litz RA and Stewart AC (2000) Research Note: Trade name franchise membership as a human resource management strategy: Does buying group training deliver 'true value' for small retailers? Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice 25(1): 125-136.
Mathewson GF and Winter RA (1985) The economics of franchise contracts, Journal of Law and Economics 28(October): 503-526.
McCosker C (1994) The growth and ongoing development of franchising as a business method: the Australian experience. Proceedings of the Culture of Business: The Russian and World Experience International Conference November. Moscow: 1-27.
Merriam SB (1985) The case in educational research: A review of selected literature, Journal of Educational Thought 19(3):4-17.
Miles MB and Huberman AM (1994) Qualitative Data Analysis: a Sourcebook for New Methods, Pergamon, Oxford.
Mintzberg H (1979) Structuring of Organizations, Prentice hall, Englewood Cliffs NJ.
Norton S (1988) An empirical look at franchising as an organisational form, Journal of Business 61(2): 197-217.
Oxenfeldt AR and Kelly AO (1968) Will successful franchise systems ultimately become wholly owned chains? Journal of Retailing 44(4): 69-83.
Patton M (2002) Qualitative Research and Evaluation Methods 3rd edn. Thousand Oaks, CA, Sage.
Perry C, Riege A and Brown L (1999) Realism's role among scientific paradigms in marketing research, Irish Marketing Review 12(2).
Robicheaux RA, Dant R and Kaufmann PJ (1994) Multiple unit franchising in the fast food industry in the united states: incidence and operating characteristics. Proceedings of the Society of Franchising, in Understanding and Accepting Different Perspectives...Empowering Relationships in 1994 and Beyond, Swerdlow S (ed), Las Vegas, Nevada, 13-14 February.
Rubin P (1978) The theory of the firm and the structure of the franchise contract, Journal of Law and Economics 21(1): 223-233.
Sen KC (2001) Information asymmetry and the franchise decision, Journal of Marketing Channels 8(1/2): 91-109.
Shane SA (1996) Hybrid organisational arrangements and their implications for firm growth and survival: A study of new franchisors, Academy of Management Journal 39(1): 216-228.
Shane SA and Foo M (1998) New firm survival: institutional explanations for new franchisor mortality, Working Paper. Cambridge, Sloan School of Management, MIT Press.
Sorenson JB (1999) The strength of corporate culture and the reliability of firm performance, Working paper, University of Chicago.
Sorenson O and SØrensen J (2001) Finding the right mix: franchising, organizational learning and chain performance, Strategic Management Journal 22 (Summer): 713- 724.
Stake RE (1990) Situational context as influence on evaluation design and use, Studies in Educational Evaluation 16: 231-246.
Stanworth J (1995) The franchise relationship: Entrepreneurship or dependence, Journal of Marketing Channels 4(1/2): 161-176.
Terry A (1993) The distribution of goods and services through business format franchising, part 1, Current Commercial Law 1(1) March: 18-23.
Thomas WL, Ohara MJ and Musgrave FW (1990) The effects of ownership and investment on the performance of franchise systems, American Economist 34(1): 54-61.
Wattel H (1968) Are franchisors realistic and successful in their selection of franchisees? Journal of Retailing 44(4) (Winter): 54-68.
Weaven S and Frazer L (2003) Predicting multiple unit franchising: a franchisor and franchisee perspective, Journal of Marketing Channels 10(3): 53-82.
Westhead P and Storey DJ (1999) Training provision and the development of small and medium-sized enterprise: A critical review, Scottish Journal of Adult and Continuing Education 5(1): 35-41.
Wolcott HE (1994) Transforming Qualitative Data: Description, Analysis and Interpretations, Thousand Oaks, California, Sage.
Yin RK (2003) Case Study Research: Design and Methods, Thousand Oaks, California, Sage.
Zarco R and Einhorn RM (1999) The Franchise Handbook, viewed 1 September 04.
Zerbe W, Dobni D and Harel G (1998) Promoting employee service behaviour: The role of perceptions of human resource management practices and service culture, Revue Canadienne des Sciences de l'Administration 15(2): 165-179.
eContent Home
