Archives
Unmasking Re-regulation in the Luxury Hotel Sector
Angela Knox
Department of Business, Macquarie University, Sydney NSW
Abstract
The pursuit of regulatory reform in order to enhance organisational flexibility and efficiency appears to be ongoing in Australia. This is particularly salient in the service sector, where competition is strong and operating hours are often extended.
In responding to these issues, government has sought to provide both employers and employees with additional regulatory options to better suit their individual needs; thereby offering what might be termed 'regulatory choice'. While employers, on average, have engaged in these alternate forms of agreement making, those within the hospitality industry have been less enthusiastic about bargaining outside of the award system. The reasons for their reluctance have not been examined in depth, however.
This paper therefore seeks to analyse the factors underpinning employers' bargaining decisions in order to develop a greater understanding of regulatory choice in Australian service sector firms. In doing so, the analysis focuses on employers' bargaining arrangements in the Australian luxury hotel sector. The findings indicate that regulatory choice is influenced by four primary factors: business/human resource management strategy; workplace characteristics; finances and perceived risk; and administrative issues.
Contrary to the government's endeavours to enhance flexibility, some employers 'choice' of employment regulation was restricted. Regulatory choice appears to be significantly more complex than anticipated.
Keywords
regulation, hotel industry, bargaining
References
Alexander R (2006) Understanding Australian industrial relations 6th edn, WorkChoices update. Melbourne: Thomson.
Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS) (2000) Employee earnings and hours. Cat No. 6306.0. Canberra: Australian Government Publishing Service (AGPS).
Australian Government. (2005) WorkChoices: A simpler, fairer national workplace relations system for Australia. Canberra: AGPS.
Buultjens J and Howard D (2001) Labour flexibility in the hospitality industry: Questioning the relevance of deregulation. International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management 13: 60-70.
Buultjens J and Luckie K (1997) 'Flexibility in the hospitality industry: Is deregulation necessary?' Paper presented to the 11th AIRAANZ Conference, Brisbane QLD, 30 January-1 February.
Commerce Queensland (2005) Workplace relations reform: Sorting fact from fiction. http://www.commerceqld.com.au/www/index.cfm?ItemIE=197
Department of Employment and Workplace Relations and the Office of the Employment Advocate (DEWR and OEA) (2004) Agreement making in Australia under the Workplace Relations Act: 2002 and 2003. Canberra: AGPS.
Department of Industrial Relations (DIR) (1989) Award restructuring: the task ahead. Canberra: AGPS.
DIR (1996) Enterprise bargaining in Australia (1995 Annual Report). Canberra: AGPS.
Ellem B, Baird M, Cooper R and Lansbury R (2005) 'WorkChoices': Mythmaking at work. Journal of Australian Political Economy 56: 13-31.
Flick U (1998) An introduction to qualitative research. London: Sage.
Hall R (2006) Australian industrial relations in 2005- The WorkChoices revolution. Journal of Industrial Relations 48: 291-303.
Holstein J and Gubrium J (1997) Active interviewing. In Silverman D (ed) Qualitative research: Theory, method and practice. London: Sage.
Hort L and Timo N (2001) 'Missing in action ? A decade of HRM and enterprise bargaining in the Australian hotel industry'. Paper presented at the Ten Years of Enterprise Bargaining Conference, Newcastle NSW, 3-4 May.
Industry Commission. (1996) Tourism accommodation and training. Melbourne: AGPS.
Keating P (1992) One nation. Canberra: AGPS.
Keating P (1994) Working nation- Policies and programs. Canberra: AGPS.
Knox A (2006) The differential effects of regulatory reform: Evidence from the Australian luxury hotel industry. Journal of Industrial Relations 48: 453-474.
Macken J (2006) Macken on WorkChoices. Sydney: Lawbook Co.
Office of the Employment Advocate (OEA) (2006) OEA research and statistics, employee coverage. http://oea.gov.au/graphics.asp?showdoc=/news/researchStatistics.asp
Patton M (1990) Qualitative evaluation and research methods. New York: Sage.
Sheldon P and Thornthwaite L (1999) Employer Matters in (1998) Journal of Industrial Relations 41: 152-169.
Timo N (1999) Contingent and retentive employment in the Australian hotel industry: Reformulating the core-periphery model. Australian Journal of Labour Economics 3: 47-64.
Timo N and Davidson M (1999) Flexible labour and human resource practices in small- to medium-sized enterprises: The case of the hotel and tourism industry in Australia. In Lee-Ross D (ed) HRM in tourism and hospitality: International Perspective on small- to medium-sized enterprises. London: Cassell.
van Barneveld K (2004) Equity and efficiency: The Case of Australian Workplace Agreements, Unpublished PhD Thesis, University of Newcastle.
van Barneveld K (2006) Hospitality. In Waring P and Bray M (eds) Evolving employment relations: Industry studies from Australia. Sydney: McGraw-Hill Irwin.
WageNet (2006) Advanced industry award search. http://www.wagenet.gov.au
Waring P, Ostenfeld S and Bray M (2004) 'Award Pull' in the hospitality industry. Paper presented at AIRAANZ Conference, Noosa, 4-6 February.
White N and Bray M (2005) The processes of workplace change for nurses in NSW public hospitals. In Stanton P, Willis E and Young S (eds) Workplace reform in the healthcare industry: The Australian Experience. Basingstoke: Palgrave.
eContent Home
