Running the Electronic Sweatshop: Call centre managers’ views on call centres
George Robinson
Graduate School of Business, Royal Melbourne Institute of Technology, Melbourne VIC
Clive Morely
Graduate School of Business, Royal Melbourne Institute of Technology, Melbourne VIC
PP: 249 - 263
Abstract
Call centres have been described as ‘electronic sweatshops' and ‘slave galleons of the twenty first century' and, contrarily as progressive, team based and career fulfilling work environments.
Drawing on data from a survey of call centre managers in Australia, it is shown that there are elements of call centre management with practices from both extremes of the descriptive continuum and in some instances these elements coexist in the one centre.
Whilst call centres are managed with a high level of control and the work of call centre agents is subject to intense scrutiny and monitoring, the simplistic notion that they are electronic sweatshops, or that the metaphor of the Panopticon applies, is rejected.
Keywords
call centres, panopticon, electronic sweatshop, managers, agents, Taylorism, electronic surveillance
References
Alferoff C and Knights D (2002) Quality time and the ‘beautiful call', in Holtgrewe U, Kerst C and Shire K (eds) Re-organising service work: Call centres in Germany and Britain, pp183-203, Ashgate, Aldershot UK.
Australian Council of Trade Unions (2002) On the Line - the Future of Australia's Call Centre Industry ACTU, Melbourne.
Robinson G and Morley CL 2006 call centre management: responsibilities and performance, International Journal of Service Industry Management 17: 284-300.
Bain P and Taylor P (2000) Entrapped by the ‘electronic panopticon'? Worker resistance in the call centre, New Technology, Work and Employment 15(1): 2-18.
Barnes A (2004) Diaries, dunnies and discipline: resistance and accommodation to monitoring in call centres, Labour and Industry 14(3): 127-137.
Batt R (2002) Managing customer services: Human resource practices, quit rates, and sales growth, Academy of Management Journal 45(3): 587-597.
Batt R and Moynihan L (2002) The viability of alternative call centre production models, Human Resource Management Journal 12(4): 14-34.
Burgess J and Connell J (2004) Emerging developments in call centre research, Labour and Industry 14(3): 1-13.
Burgess J and Connell J (2006) Developments in the call centre industry: an overview, in Burgess J and Connell, J (eds) Developments in the call centre industry: analysis, changes and challenges pp.1-18, Routledge, London and New York.
Callaghan G and Thompson P (2001). Edwards revisited: Technical control and call centres, Economic and Industrial Democracy 22(1): 15-37.
D'Alessio N and Oberbeck H (2002) Call centres as organisational crystallisation of new labour relations, working conditions and a new service culture? in Holtgrewe U, Kerst C and Shire K (eds) Re-organising service work: Call centres in Germany and Britain pp.80-101, Ashgate, Aldershot UK.
Deery S (2006) Foreword, in Burgess J and Connell J (eds) Developments in the call centre industry: analysis, changes and challenges pp.xvi-xv, Routledge, London and New York.
Dose C (2002) Call centres and the contradictions of the flexible bureaucracy, in Holtgrewe U, Kerst C and Shire K (eds) Re-organising service work: Call centres in Germany and Britain pp.146-160, Ashgate, Aldershot UK.
Edwards R (1984) Forms of control in the labor process: An historical analysis, in Fischer F and Sirriani C (eds) Organization and bureaucracy pp.109-42, Philadelphia, PA, Temple University Press.
Fernie S and Metcalf D (1998) (Not) Hanging on the telephone: Payments systems in the new sweatshops, Centre for Economic Performance, London School of Economics, London.
Foucault M (1977) Discipline and punish: The birth of the prison, Harmondsworth, Penguin.
Frenkel S, Korczynski M, Shire K and Tam M (1998) Beyond bureaucracy? Work organisation in call centres, International Journal of Human Resource Management 9(6): 957-979.
Frenkel S and Donoghue L (1996) Call centres and service excellence, CCC Paper No. 066, Australian Graduate School of Management, Sydney, University of New South Wales.
Holtgrewe U, Kerst C and Shire K (2002a) Re-organising service work: an introduction, in Holtgrewe U, Kerst C and Shire K (eds) Re-organising service work: Call centres in Germany and Britain, Ashgate, Aldershot UK.
Holtgrewe U, Kerst C and Shire K (eds) (2002b) Re-organising service work: Call centres in Germany and Britain, Ashgate, Aldershot UK
Houlihan M (2006) Agency and constraint: call centre managers talk about their work, in Burgess J and Connell J (eds) Developments in the call centre industry: analysis, changes and challenges pp.152-169, Routledge, London and New York.
Kinnie N, Hutchison S and Purcell J (2000) ‘Fun and surveillance': The paradox of high commitment management in call centres, International Journal of Human Resource Management 11(6): 967-985.
Knights D, Calvey D and Odih P (1999) Social managerialism and the time disciplined subject: Quality-quantity conflicts in a call centre. Paper presented at the 17th International Labour Process Conference, Royal Holloway, London.
Koskina A (2006) How ‘Taylorised' is call centre work: the sphere of customer practice in Greece, in Burgess J and Connell J (eds) Developments in the call centre industry: analysis, changes and challenges pp.170-188, Routledge, London and New York.
Lee B-H and Kang H-Y (2006) A nationals survey of Korean call centres, in Burgess J and Connell J (eds) Developments in the call centre industry: analysis, changes and challenges pp.75-91, Routledge, London and New York.
Lindgren A and Sederblad P (2006) Escaping the electronic birdcage: workplace strategies in Swedish call centres, in Burgess J and Connell J (eds) Developments in the call centre industry: analysis, changes and challenges pp.189-198, Routledge, London and New York.
Mulholland K (1999) Back to the future: A call centre and new forms of direct control. Paper presented at the 17th International Labour Process Conference, Royal Holloway, London.
Paulet R (2004) Putting call centres in their place, Labour and Industry 14(3): 77-89.
Porter ME (1985) Competitive Advantage: Creating and sustaining superior performance, The Free Press, New York.
Russell B (2002) The talk shop and shop talk: Employment and work in a call centre, Journal of Industrial Relations 44(4): 467-490.
Russell B (2004) Are all call centres the same? Labour and Industry 14(3): 91-109.
Sewell G (1998) The discipline of teams: The control of team-based industrial work through electronic and peer surveillance, Administrative Science Quarterly 43: 406-69.
Taylor P and Bain P (1999). ‘An assembly line in the head': Work and employee relations in the call centre, Industrial Relations Journal 30(2): 101-17.
Taylor P and Bain P (2006) Work organisation and employee relations in Indian call centres, in Burgess J and Connell J (eds) Developments in the call centre industry: analysis, changes and challenges pp.36-57, Routledge, London and New York.
van den Broek D (2004) Globalising call centre capital: gender, culture and work identity, Labour and Industry 14(3): 59-75.
Wallace CM, Eagleson G and Waldersee R (2000) The sacrificial HR strategy in call centers, International Journal of Service Industry Management 11(2): 174-84.
Weinkopf C (2006) German call centres between service orientation and efficiency: ‘the polyphony of telephony', in Burgess J and Connell J (eds) Developments in the call centre industry: analysis, changes and challenges pp.58-74, Routledge, London and New York.
eContent Home
